Have any questions about how to use the community? Check out the Help Discussion.

Hearing, Yes or No?

It is too late for my dear wife as she left us a few weeks ago. As I often sit and think back over our path down the difficult road of AD, things pop into my head that I wish I had known or at least considered at the start. One of those topics is the subject of how much the suffering person can hear and also understand, especially in the later stages. As our loved one loses the ability to communicate in the normal ways, we are required to learn how to communicate with them in their world, whether that be signs, facial expressions, behaviors, etc. Their hearing is supposed to be the last to go, but their ability to communicate verbally may have left much earlier. I found that this seemed to cause others, including nurses, to speak more openly about the condition in the presence of the loved one, assuming they could not understand. I want to caution anyone walking along this path of caregiving a loved one to be cautious. Over the course of my wife's path and I realized late, i now believe that the loved one does hear and, to some degree, maybe completely, understand what is said. As I look back, I now recall several circumstances when a conversation had taken place in the presence of my wife, assuming a lack of understanding on her part, only to shortly after have her repeat some part of the conversation back to me, often in a question. There were occasions when I would discuss making a change to something for her safety or to prevent her access, and then find her changing her behavior to remove the need. I now fear that she heard discussions about her disease and details she never needed to know which may have been understood at some level. I will close with the last occasion. A week prior to her passing she became soiled requiring me to clean her. It was quite difficult as she was more weak, unable to stand reliably alone and quite unhappy with what I had to do. In the course of this I became frustrated and struggled to complete the task. Finished, I helped her back to her seat on the sofa. She then gently took both my hands in hers, looked into my eyes with an angelic face and said" You are not going to put me somewhere are you?" That was a stab into my heart. I started crying and reassured her I would not, not knowing why she asked this at that time. I then realized that in the midst of the struggle cleaning her up, I said out loud, but I thought to myself "I don't know how much longer I can do this". Some will argue her question following this experience is just coincidence and they two things are not related. I would ask them "Exactly how you do you know that for sure?" I encourage you to be cautious, don't assume anything about things which we cannot measure or confirm and be sensitive to your loved one at all times. Better safe than sorry. You do not want to experience your loved one playing back to you something said with the assumption they cannot hear or understand. It is a stab into your heart from which you may never recover.

Comments

  • Biggles
    Biggles Member Posts: 519
    500 Care Reactions 250 Likes 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Comments
    Member

    Thank you so much for this gentle reminder not to get frustrated and short tempered in the heat of the moment in earshot of our loved ones; feeling sorry afterwards just makes things worse. Thank you, I hope your DW is resting in peace I also hope peace will come to you.

  • Michele P
    Michele P Member Posts: 130
    100 Comments 25 Likes 25 Insightfuls Reactions 5 Care Reactions
    Member

    I am so sorry for your loss. We had two experiences with my mother-in-law who had Alzheimer’s related to knowing what is going on and hearing. When she was in later stages, she a moment of lucidity and asked what was happening to her. She continued to tell us that she never met to be a burden to us. Prior to this, her conversations made no sense. Then when she was in the final stage, bed ridden with fist clutched and not speaking for two years, she began speaking the day her husband died. For hours, she spoke with family members. She was aware of what we were doing to care for her and our promise to her husband to keep her home with round the clock care.

  • marier
    marier Member Posts: 122
    Seventh Anniversary 100 Comments 100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    My deepest condolences on the loss of your DW. THANK YOU so much for this heartfelt post/reminder of what our loved ones may hear or sense when we are speaking to them or to others about them. I am so guilty of thinking my DH doesn't understand or hear me when I am speaking. (stage 7) On occasion out of the blue he repeats or asks a question about statement I made in front of him. I really need to be cautious of what I say. Again thank you for this reminder.

  • BPS
    BPS Member Posts: 348
    250 Care Reactions 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments
    Member

    One of the things I was surprised about early on was how doctors would say things and ask questions in front of my wife that I felt were questions they should ask privately because they would be very blunt and seemed to embarrass my wife. They needed the information but it felt like they could have the nurse take her out of the room to weigh her or anything then ask. I understand they don't have extra time or staff but it was uncomfortable at first.

  • Timmyd
    Timmyd Member Posts: 219
    100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Comments 100 Likes 100 Care Reactions
    Member
    edited September 27

    Thank you for sharing your insight. DW is in stage 6 and unable to engage or respond to conversation. However I can tell she reacts differently based upon the conversations occurring in her presence. I have decided I will always assume that she hears and understands what is spoken in her presence and ensure those in her company behave similarly. It should not be considered burden to extend such a simple courtesy.

  • AlzWife2023
    AlzWife2023 Member Posts: 409
    250 Care Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments Second Anniversary
    Member

    Don't feel badly. You took excellent care of your wife and loved her. When she asked you that question you gave her the answer she wanted to hear & it was the truth. God bless you and know that your beautiful wife appreciates you and is resting in peace. We all makes these slips and our loved ones forgive us.

  • JulietteBee
    JulietteBee Member Posts: 265
    100 Comments 25 Insightfuls Reactions 25 Likes 25 Care Reactions
    Member

    As a nursing instructor, I can state that the sense of hearing is indeed the last to go.

    I would often ream students & staff members out if they gave report directly at their comatose patient's bedside. That is 100% taboo. 💔

  • howhale
    howhale Member Posts: 95
    100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions 25 Likes 10 Comments
    Member

    When I realized that my dear wife must be able to hear and understand some of what was being said I gave specific direction to the hospice nurses and caregivers NOT to talk about her, her condition or behavior within earshot of her. I am so sorry that this is not better recognized and was not recognized much sooner by me. I fear that she overheard things that could only add to her fear, sense of being lost and despair. I encourage anyone caring for a loved one to protect what is said in their presence from the start. It is a terrible feeling to think now that I allowed myself or others to comment about her and that she heard and/or understood a word of what was said. It is like the song "One More Day' , if I could have just one more day to tell her how sorry I am that I allowed her to ever hear anything that may have caused her grief, scared her or in any way upset her. Just another reason for caregivers of this horrible disease to find access to this site and begin to learn very early on.

  • persevere
    persevere Member Posts: 41
    25 Likes 25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    Howhale, I could not agree more with what you are saying. My wife is very far along and I too notice her changing things up slightly whenever she hears something that might be disturbing to her. I too am guilty of letting loose with things when my stress meter is pegged. I have to stop that and I have to make others be careful what they say in front of her! I think you are right - they are hearing and understanding a lot more than we think.

Commonly Used Abbreviations


DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more