Have any questions about how to use the community? Check out the Help Discussion.

projecting future costs and availability of funds

Today I learned that your investment person, or financial advisor, or ??? can put your information into a spreadsheet that projects how long someone's funds will last if they enter memory care at a given date. Intuitively I knew this could be done but it had never been suggested to me in a "you ought to do this now" sort of way. So I pulled some numbers from a bank statement and reached out to our investment guy and we'll see what he comes up with.

For those of you who have done this already, what other information is important to consider during this process? Funds in, from all sources. Assets in the PWD's name. Liabilities. Estimated monthly cost of a couple different MC facilities in the area. Other than the monthly cost of MC, how have you budgeted for the unplanned and the incidentals? Do you include the out of pocket limit on your insurance as a budget item, or just the deductible and project medical expenses based on the past couple years? Income tax on the investment income? All household expenses, property taxes, etc become the responsibility of the partner who remains in the house, correct?

In my mind, this is sort of a hybrid of the exercise they do at retirement time, and a look-ahead to the need for Medicaid. I'll have a longer conversation with the investment guy later in the week, but I'm wondering what I might be missing. What did you plan for and what surprises did you have, in terms of budget?

Comments

  • sherryandwilliam
    sherryandwilliam Member Posts: 41
    25 Likes 25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    Only thing I know if I self paid the money would be gone so fast then he would have to go on medicaid. It is so expensive!. Either you are rich enough to be able to afford it or poor enough to be able to go the medicaid route without losing anything. The middle group is the ones that pull their hair out trying to figure it out

  • allit
    allit Member Posts: 110
    25 Likes 10 Comments 5 Care Reactions 5 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I just said the same thing to my wife today! Pretty much the exact same thing! Freaky

  • Jeanne C.
    Jeanne C. Member Posts: 842
    500 Likes 500 Care Reactions 500 Comments 100 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    you may also want to consult a CELA (yes, I know we always say that - insert eye roll). The reason I say it here is because I found my investment guy to be clueless about longterm care in our state. The CELA was able to help me move assets legally out my husband’s name and into mine using a Medicaid compliant annuity. We’re solidly middle class, but we were able to qualify him for Medicaid through careful planning. Not saying your investment person will be clueless but mine would have steered me very wrong.

  • HollyBerry
    HollyBerry Member Posts: 187
    100 Comments Second Anniversary 25 Insightfuls Reactions 25 Care Reactions
    Member

    I realized I never followed up on this. I was disappointed in the result. While he's been reassuring me for a couple years that she has plenty of money for memory care, in the end, I'm not sure he really understood what I needed to know and how much life will cost! I am going back to my own spreadsheets, trying to figure out what we really spend on things now, what I will need to assume when she's no longer contributing to household expenses, what else she will need funds for besides memory care (insurance… health care…). On the positive side, he moved some of her investments into different funds that provide more income and we have a long term plan for that (I guess). I'm still concerned but not quite as worried.

  • Jazzma
    Jazzma Member Posts: 126
    Sixth Anniversary 100 Comments 100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I strongly recommend a CELA lawyer. There are ways to legally shelter some of your assets, and to qualify your LO for Medicaid assistance. Memory care expenses are horrific.

  • cdgbdr
    cdgbdr Member Posts: 97
    25 Likes 25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I am new to this but am working with a CELA. Even at a high level, I know how long I could pay for MC or AL privately and how I can manage what we have and apply for Medicaid protecting as much as possible under current rules. I recommend this. I'm pretty savvy but she has helped me a lot.

  • DWTired
    DWTired Member Posts: 51
    25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions 5 Likes
    Member

    That depends on state you live in correct!

  • Victoriaredux
    Victoriaredux Member Posts: 170
    100 Likes 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Comments 25 Care Reactions
    Member

    "On the positive side, he moved some of her investments into different funds that provide more income and we have a long term plan for that (I guess). I'm still concerned but not quite as worried."

    An investment person does, well -investments ; a LTC agent sells insurance etc. You need a comprehensive game plan from someone who plans for the situation you are in . Who considers taxes, medicaid, inheritance, how to title assets, trusts, etc . That would be an elder law attorney .

    Grinding numbers is good but having the assets in the right place first is better.

    [That the investment person moved funds and wasn't, obviously a retirement planner,which you were seeking, bugs me— I'd check if these funds were no load. They pay more but do they present more risk? I'd just be sure that your retirement benefitted from the changes made and not just theirs.

    My fav stock broker joke: A long time ago, a visitor from out of town came to a tour in Manhattan. At the end of the tour they took him to the financial district. When they arrived to Battery Park the guide showed him some nice yachts anchoringthere, and said, "Here are the yachts of our bankers and stockbrokers.""And where are the yachts of the investors?" asked the naive visitor.]

  • Quilting brings calm
    Quilting brings calm Member Posts: 2,613
    2500 Comments 500 Care Reactions 500 Likes Fourth Anniversary
    Member
    edited November 2024

    in answer to your original question about a future budget… you include all income and savings your loved one has, and all expenses your loved one will be responsible for.

    My parents have been in an AL for 5 years, so here’s this for an example.

    Income

    Social security ( each) average of 2% increase a year. But so will the Medicare premium that is deducted before the money goes to your checking account.

    Pension ( each) a pittance for mom, neither increases ever.

    Their savings - including the money from the sale of their home ( they moved into a camper). They had cashed out their 401k long ago and put everything in a lowly interest bearing checking account. Don’t bother budgeting for interest income

    Expenses

    Rent at AL - second person charge, first person charge goes up at least 5% every year. Sometimes an unexpected increase due to inflation or ‘whatever’.

    Health insurance -Medicare supplement - goes up at least 10% every year. Dental, eye insurance.

    Any medical, dental, eye bill that isn’t covered by insurance. Including the bill at the local pharmacy that delivers to the AL.

    Car/car insurance/maintenance - some people in AL still drive.

    Cell phone or landline.

    Groceries - snacks, personal hygiene, hearing aid batteries, depends etc. AL supplies none of this.

    Clothing and other items like it.

    Haircuts.

    Any item they might buy on an outing.

    Roku, Netflix, cable, etc.


    Net result - income was less than expenses. They began using their savings the day they moved into the AL. They were up to pulling $2000 a month out of savings when he died in February this year and mom needed $1200 a month since then. The ‘savings’ would have been gone in two more years.

  • Quilting brings calm
    Quilting brings calm Member Posts: 2,613
    2500 Comments 500 Care Reactions 500 Likes Fourth Anniversary
    Member

    @fmb

    Excellent point about the extra care charge. Mom’s AL changed from all inclusive to additional charges a year or so ago. She just got moved from the base rate to Level 2 in October. I had to ask what that meant. Shower help, dressing help, bringing meals to her room. The charge landed as soon as she went on hospice. However I think the shower and dressing help preceded that, but they just weren’t charging her. Around the date she went on hospice, she started refusing to go to the dining hall and within a few days all meals were being delivered to her. She’s been on hospice 5 weeks.

    I could not make it through the last 3 weeks or the coming week ( I hope it’s only 1 more) without hospice, the AL nurse and the resident CNA and aid ( those two positions are on every shift). I’d gladly pay multiple times the extra monthly charge of $200 for the two on one care she’s getting, while they also take care of everyone else.

  • fmb
    fmb Member Posts: 508
    250 Care Reactions 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments
    Member

    @Quilting brings calm

    Here in PA, the facility is required to periodically update and review the resident's care plan with the POA/responsible party. I can't remember if it is every 3 mos. or 6 mos. They are also required to review the plan with you if interim changes are made. I imagine your state has similar regulations. You shouldn't have had to ask.

    I am so grateful that DH's Medicare Advantage plan covers his hospice charges. His last statement showed that hospice charged over $5700 for the month of September. The plan paid nearly $4500. We wouldn't have made it through the past year without the exemplary care DH is receiving from his hospice team. They are well worth every penny they charge.

    I could not make it through the last 3 weeks or the coming week ( I hope it’s only 1 more) … Still praying for your and your mom (hug)

  • Bill_2001
    Bill_2001 Member Posts: 136
    Fifth Anniversary 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Comments 100 Likes
    Member

    This is a very needed, and quite frankly, frightening topic.

    It seems to me that all of the budgeting advice being given by financial advisors ought to include saving for nursing care starting in one's 20s. Let's see how far that goes. Young people are struggling to just move out of their parents' house. It wasn't easy for us older people either, but today's youth have it much harder.

    The immense expense of nursing/memory care cannot realistically be budgeted and planned in advance. A few very lucky ones out there have long term care insurance, but most of us will be scrambling to figure it out on demand. For most of us, it might as well cost a million dollars a month.

    An elder law attorney and financial advisor are necessary to help us put together a plan. I will offer this: Many retired people do plan on spending money travelling and enjoying their golden years. When dementia enters the scene, those plans end anyway, so those funds can go toward care. This is heartbreaking; no one wants to spend their life savings on care when they had dreams of retirement bliss. However, at least there is a source of funds, even if not quite enough. After much kicking and screaming (at the death of a dream), I promise you that logic will set in and you will come up with a plan.

    You may need to give up something and downsize. You may need to search far and wide for a more affordable facility. There are so many variables, and many of us here have cobbled together very different solutions to the same problem.

    I learned years ago that the Cavalry is Not Coming, and that includes the financial Cavalry. If you Google "how to pay for memory care," the solutions are as painful as the problem itself. "Sell the house." "Tap retirement funds." "Ask family for help." "Apply for Medicaid." UGH. Wow, artificial intelligence telling me how to slowly go broke. Gee whiz.

    I feel for everyone in this ordeal. But I like to give solid, hopeful advice, so here you go.

    Consider all income: Social Security, pensions, etc. Now look at your own expenses, plus nursing/memory care for your loved one.

    Any monthly shortfall must be pulled from retirement accounts and savings. Do some quick math to get an idea how long your funds will last. Take this information to your elder care attorney and financial advisor and let them help you protect your funds and/or make your funds last as long as possible.

    Much Love, Bill_2001

  • fairytale36
    fairytale36 Member Posts: 3
    First Comment
    Member

    I'm realizing that I might not be selecting the best option for my DD. He needs to move for a higher level of care. Did you target a community that could accept a catheter, or did you just stumble into it? I'm not sure AL/MC in CA will accept a catheter. Though whether or not on hospice maybe makes a difference?

  • LindaLouise
    LindaLouise Member Posts: 111
    100 Comments 100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions 25 Likes
    Member

    So much truth here. Many of our PWD have a clear diagnosis of Alzheimer's or FTD or another specific dementia. Some - like my DH - have delusions and psychoses that make living at home incredibly difficult and dangerous, with frequent "escapes" and angry, fearful episodes. My DH has been in MC now for 8 months, though I planned to keep him at home. For couples like us, there is no financial help beyond our savings and Social security - and a very small long term care policy purchased years ago. Imagine if you were diagnosed with any other disease that needed treatment, such as cancer. Can you imagine being told - That disease? Sorry, its not covered and you will have to pay for any necessary treatment out of pocket. That is our situation, if we have a PWD we care for that needs full time care for his and our safety. It's the same if your LO needs physical care you can't provide, or you need sleep to continue care giving. Medicare won't pay for the help you need. Oddly, it will pay for expensive new drugs, but not physical care. I hope someday Medicare will pay for physical care for PWD in Stages 6 and 7 - it seems like that is a reasonable thing to hope for!

  • fmb
    fmb Member Posts: 508
    250 Care Reactions 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments
    Member

    @fairytale36

    DH ended up in the ALF where he resides out of sheer desperation. After 6 hospitalizations and 2 rehab stays in 4-1/2 months for various reasons (stroke, falls, extremely high BP, entrenched UTI, etc.), he was firmly in Stage 6 with a chronic Foley catheter, stroke damage, and 7 broken ribs from a bad fall. He was at the end of his Medicare allotment of rehab days. I had contacted every SNF within 1 hr. driving distance (Pittsburgh area) and received only one return call, and they weren't interested when they learned of his ALZ diagnosis. They wanted $15,000/mo. We would have been private pay.

    The personal care facility where he had lived only 6 days when he had a very severe fall resulting in broken ribs refused to take him back because he had become a 2-person lift and had a catheter. In violation of their policies, they kept our entire entry fee and 11 days worth of charges after the move out to the end of the month because I couldn't provide 30 days notice.

    I was literally in tears and at the end of my rope (actually considered murder/suicide) when the rehab social worker told me about an ALF that would take 2-person transfer residents. This ALF had a probationary license due to mismanagement by the previous Director and was desperate for residents. The Director came to the rehab, evaluated DH, spoke with me, and I agreed to move him there sight unseen. He moved in the day before Thanksgiving 2023. I enrolled him in hospice the same day. This facility is located @45 minutes away.

    Pressure was put on me to have DH get a suprapubic catheter, but in the state of PA, he would then have had to reside in a SNF. Because he was in hospice care, he could live in the ALF because the hospice RN changes his Foley catheter. He has required a Hoyer lift for many months, making a trip to a urologist's office impossible.

    Check the regulations in your state regarding catheters in facilities. When you interview facilities, be sure to speak with the Nursing Director or Facility Director to be very clear on their policies regarding catheters and other aspects of aging-in-place.

  • frankay
    frankay Member Posts: 49
    Second Anniversary 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions 5 Care Reactions
    Member

    I ditto on everything fmb writes. When touring facilities in the beginning, it never entered my mind to ask questions about lifts, 2 person transfers and what happens when the patient becomes incontinent, immobile, can't stand, needs a catheter or even if they will allow them to be bedridden. What happens if they have a fall or needs to go to the hospital or rehab, Ask what exactly does aging in place mean to that facility. When you're touring facilities in the earlier stages, it's normal to be more interested in the food, activities and care of DH in his current state especially when you have no idea what's going to happen or even understand the progression of this awful disease. Tour guides will probably not volunteer this information so you must ask questions.

  • housefinch
    housefinch Member Posts: 445
    100 Care Reactions 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments
    Member
    edited January 21

    @fmb I was really shaken reading your post. I think your description of your state of mind drives home the desperation people feel when caregiving. It captured what many people who swear they’ll keep family at home do not realize can happen. I’m so sorry you reached that point. Our family currently pays around $8000/mo for a shared room in SNF for 24/7 care for our PWD in stage 7 on hospice.

    The financial planning is so important, for whatever caregiving situation, and yet so scary and challenging. We have a child who will need lifelong support and were told by our specialist financial planner to have $1 million left over when we die. For her support. That’s because the disability funding only supports our child enough to “keep her out of a gutter.” It is disheartening on a good day and terrifying on a hard one. Sending you comfort.

Commonly Used Abbreviations


DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more