Have any questions about how to use the community? Check out the Help Discussion.

parent telling me mean things about sibling

peacelove
peacelove Member Posts: 2
First Comment
Member
edited May 19 in Caring for a Parent

Hi all, first time poster, I've had this come up recently and wondered if I'm the only one. My sibling and I each equally care for our parent, several times, my parent with dementia will say to me they prefer me to my sibling, this really breaks my heart because my sibling does so much for my parent and always, our whole lives, I thought our parent loved us equally. When they say these things I hope it's just the dementia talking but I'm unsure how to react, so far I just remind them how much my sibling loves them. Has anyone else dealing with dementia parent experienced this? It's so sad and unnerving to me.

Comments

  • psg712
    psg712 Member Posts: 489
    100 Care Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I think that your response is fine, reminding her that your sibling loves her. There isn't much to say to challenge her favoritism, and nothing will change her mind. Most PWD get attached to one caregiver and prefer that person. But no one person can carry the responsibility alone for extended time. It's great that your sib shares the caregiving with you. Expressing your appreciation to him/her doesn't change the sting of being the non-preferred caregiver, but at least they know they are valued as a partner in the struggle.

  • SDianeL
    SDianeL Member Posts: 1,611
    500 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Likes 1000 Comments 500 Care Reactions
    Member

    wonder if she’s saying the same thing to your sibling? What psg712 said. They may get more attached to one caregiver. It’s also caused by delusions and mixing up memories.

  • harshedbuzz
    harshedbuzz Member Posts: 5,190
    Eighth Anniversary 5000 Comments 1,000 Insightfuls Reactions 1,000 Likes
    Member

    @peacelove

    Hi and welcome. I am sorry for your reason to be here, but pleased you found this place.

    Firstly, I want to call out your strategy of reassuring your mom that sibling loves her. That is absolutely the best response to this behavior. Kudos to you.

    This is definitely the disease talking. This can come from a couple of places, sometimes there are conflated memories in which the emotional gist of the story are true, but the details about who, what, where, etc. are confused. My dad often ascribed terrible things my sister did to me. This was upsetting initially until I understood it as a disease symptom.

    I think sometimes, too, that short term memory makes it as if a PWD can't recall the kindness displayed 5 minutes ago much less yesterday or last week. They live in-the-moment. Her reality is you're there and sib isn't. As SDianeL mentioned, there's a real likelihood your sibling has heard the same or worse about you.

    Another piece is that some PWD have considerable anxiety and a sense of vulnerability and will try to manipulate you much as a toddler might. My dad also did this in the later stages. FTR, I knew that historically I was about his least favorite family member so this lavish praise was kind of amusing.

    HB

  • peacelove
    peacelove Member Posts: 2
    First Comment
    Member

    Thanks so much everyone, this happens when my sibling and I are there at the same time, so, is good to know it's probably the disease talking. I haven't mentioned these words to my sibling yet because to me it would seem so hurtful when they are trying even harder than I am to help, so, if it happens again I'll just use my same strategy. Thanks for your responses everyone.

  • H1235
    H1235 Member Posts: 891
    250 Likes 500 Comments 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Care Reactions
    Member

    It could also just be your siblings approach. I’m not suggesting they are doing anything wrong, more that it can be hard to choose the right words when trying to convince a lo to do something. There could be something minor that is causing your parent to become upset. It could also be that your sibling has taken responsibility for something your parent is having a very difficult time giving up. Dementia is awful!

  • Niecey2loved1
    Niecey2loved1 Member Posts: 19
    10 Comments 5 Care Reactions
    Member

    Yes. Though not my parent, my aunt would do this to me about my cousin. She was constantly telling me how my sister and I were her favorite, which wasn't true because she moved out of state to be near our cousin. Her other niece. She would tell us we were prettier and nicer than our cousin. We didn't like it one bit and would plead with her not to say these things.

    Well now, the shoe is on the other foot. Since we (sis and I) can no longer prop her up by giving aunt everything she wants, we are now the bad guys and cousin is now the favorite again.

    Dementia is a horrible, horrible disease. I pray 🙏🏽 I don't get it. It really tears families apart.

  • Red-Blue
    Red-Blue Member Posts: 1
    First Comment
    Member

    my grandmother would not be nice to my oldest Aunt her daughter. Even though she was the one who took care of her. Now I am taking care of my mother and she does the same thing to me but it is mostly behind my back. She tells my brother crazy things like I throw her clothes out in the street. He understands though. I get sad about it but I’ve seen it before. My concern is that Mom will say something crazy to someone who does not understand.I have listened to her through “Ring” at the front door tell a solicitor how bossy I am and how mean I treat her.

  • middlechild5
    middlechild5 Member Posts: 5
    5 Care Reactions First Comment
    Member
    edited May 22

    I am so sorry u are going through this my mom does the same thing. She tells me how hateful I am and that I hate her. These things are so hard to hear especially when I’m trying my best to do for my mother. I sometimes wonder and doubt if this is really her and not the disease. This really messes with my psych. Today she just kept saying it over and over and when I left her presence I just had a breakdown. I just screamed and screamed and screamed because it’s so much. Sometimes I feel like I just should do something just to stop the emotional pain and hurt. I am so down. She always sics God on me and I’m starting to believe her. My mom also says all kinds of things that aren’t true. She hasn’t eaten in days, not being taken care of, her money is being stolen, not getting her mail so I have the concern as well that somebody might actually believe her because when she’s around other people she seems quite ok. She talks normal although things that she remembers and says aren’t true but only family knows that. I worked for the human services for 32 years and I know if someone reports neglect or abuse it has to be investigated.

  • christine1987
    christine1987 Member Posts: 1
    First Comment
    Member
    edited June 4

    I am glad I came across your post. I really feel you when you say it messes with your psych. My mom is recently widowed, and just turned 70. My sibling has honestly been carrying most of the load. Their schedule is more flexible to be able to go and help her, take her to appointments, do stuff around the house, etc. We've both been concerned about sudden changes with my mom's memory and behaviors. We decided one of us should go with her to her doctor appointment and start the conversation. Not both of us, so she wouldn't feel attacked. The doctor gave her an assessment and said she was borderline. But it could be due to other symptoms like depression and insomnia. She was reevaluated about 6 months later, and unfortunately neither of us could go with her. Her scored improved by 1 point. To which, she boasts she doesn't have dementia and nothing is wrong with her. However, when I was visiting her one day, I found that she had written down some very hurtful things about me. Written as if she had planned to read it to someone, like a script. I suspect she said it to her doctor because it had listed medications she was on, how she was feeling, etc. But she also wrote that I am telling people I think she has dementia so I can "declare her incompetent" and take her assets. She also specifically stated that my sibling does NOT think she has dementia. I've also noticed that when I am around she keeps her purse with her at all times, she even takes it to the bathroom with her. I made the rookie mistake of confronting her about the letter moments after finding it because I basically burst into tears. We do not do confrontation in our family, so this was super difficult. She claimed she didn't write it, but she couldn't deny it when she yanked it out of my hand. Then she scoffed and acted like it wasn't a big deal. I am having a hard time not taking it personal and just thinking it's just the disease. I feel like she truly believes what she wrote. It's really messing with me. And I'm struggling.

Commonly Used Abbreviations


DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more