Am I the crazy one?

my DH has a diagnosis of MCI. I’ve posted here about driving and most opinions here are that he shouldn’t be driving. I’m ready to address it with him and do a driving assessment but am getting a lot of pushback from people who are my support system. My therapist said that if he stops driving he won’t be able to keep his skills current. Others are saying that the doctor didn’t address it in our initial conversation so I’m jumping the gun. I’m worried that I’m overreacting. Please help!

Comments

  • H1235
    H1235 Member Posts: 2,466
    1,000 Likes 1,000 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Care Reactions 1000 Comments
    Member

    Your support system doesn’t seem very supportive! I think doctors are hesitant to take driving away. I imagine they could get a lot of pushback. To avoid problems most probably just avoid the topic all together. That doesn’t mean he is fine to drive. We were very fortunate that moms doctor recommended she stop driving (on the same day she was diagnosed). Even eye doctors dealing with vision are not required to report patients to dmv that should not be driving (in my state). It’s unfortunate that this difficult decision is left in the hands of the caregiver who is overwhelmed with everything. You are talking about getting an assessment not just taking the keys. This seem very reasonable and level headed to me. If he doesn’t pass what exactly would be the point in keeping his driving skills current? Driving when he is not capable puts his life in danger and anyone on the road with him. The price is just too high to take any chances in my opinion.

  • jgreen
    jgreen Member Posts: 575
    500 Likes 250 Care Reactions 500 Comments 250 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    Dear @Lisa1022

    The Alzheimer’s Association has this information about driving:

    https://www.alz.org/help-support/caregiving/safety/dementia-driving

    I read where it is good to include your support system in the planning. You might want to share this link with them and then tell your support persons that you, as the primary caregiver, are going to make the final decision.

  • Michele P
    Michele P Member Posts: 572
    500 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Comments 250 Likes 25 Care Reactions
    Member

    We were told that with MCI, driving is impaired due to a neurodegenerative disease. If your insurance company does not cover the accident or another driver sues you, you can lose everything you own because he should not have been driving. A facility that accesses if he is safe to drive can give him a three hour test to determine if he is safe to drive. Safety is always number one. The people who are giving you this advice don’t know what they are talking about. He can appear to be safe to drive one day and get into an accident the next. Spacial orientation, reaction time, confusion, and short term memory loss all impact decisions while driving.

  • Lisa1022
    Lisa1022 Member Posts: 19
    25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Likes
    Member

    Thank you so much, this really resonated with me. I've been told all my life that I overreact, am too emotional, et (hence the therapy haha) which is why I'm not trusting myself with this decision. I'm so grateful to have found this forum with people who know what's going on.

  • BPS
    BPS Member Posts: 569
    500 Likes 500 Care Reactions 500 Comments 250 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    My wife in early stages was still driving and doing fine then she had two small accidents and we decided that she shouldn't drive any more. Thankfully they were small accidents and no one was hurt, but I realized that her problem was that her field of vision had narrowed and her depth perception had changed, and her reaction time had slowed. As long as nothing happened to quick she was fine, but any unexpected thing that happens all the time driving was a problem. She seemed fine until she didn't and it could have cost someone a serious injury or death.

  • Maru
    Maru Member Posts: 594
    500 Likes 500 Care Reactions 250 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Comments
    Member

    In my state if you are impaired in any way, any accident you are in is automatically your fault…that would certainly include a dementia diagnosis. I agree with H135, your support system is subpar. It is hard enough being THE responsible one for everything without your support system cutting off your legs.

  • Maru
    Maru Member Posts: 594
    500 Likes 500 Care Reactions 250 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Comments
    Member

    Oh, and by the way, get used to feeling like you are the crazy one. PWD can seem perfectly normal most of the time,…and then the light bulb flickers our and you see it. Driving becomes dangerous because you don't know when that light bulb is going to flicker off.

  • notequipped
    notequipped Member Posts: 186
    100 Likes 100 Comments 25 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I have wondered many times how often when you see things like that if that is the case.

    At every appointment that I went to with my Mom, she was asked if she was still driving. Since no one objected when she said yes, I took that to mean that it was fine. While she did not get in an accident, she was absolutely not fine. I let my Mom take a SAGE test during one of our many discussions about driving which started when I would no longer let her drive after she was unable to figure out how to get in the car with the keys in her hand when the key fob didn’t work. She scored a 6 on that test (scores of 14 and lower are indicative of a serious issue). I scanned and forwarded the test to her PCP who agreed with me and told my Mom that she should no longer drive at her next appointment. The time from MCI to scoring a 6 on a SAGE was less than 2 years (an ~5 hour neuro psych evaluation just after the SAGE test characterized her cognitive impairment as severe). My point in relating this is that if a driving test indicates that he is fine to drive today, how will you know when he’s no longer fine? Are you going to repeat the driving test yearly? Maybe monthly? With my Mom, there was not a slow gradual progression. She probably was fine, until she wasn’t. I have no idea when she crossed that line.

    I get questioning yourself. Everyone, and I do mean everyone, questioned my decision at first. It is extremely difficult to take away someone else’s independence and is not a step to be taken lightly. Looking in from the outside is very different than living with and seeing the day to day changes.

    All the best to you.

  • Lisa1022
    Lisa1022 Member Posts: 19
    25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Likes
    Member

    that is a very good way to express it and we’re the ones that see every reaction and and flicker to everyone else, they’re fine

  • Quilting brings calm
    Quilting brings calm Member Posts: 3,317
    Sixth Anniversary 1,000 Insightfuls Reactions 1,000 Likes 2500 Comments
    Member

    I agree with everyone else. In addition, be aware that 2) an MCI diagnosis is often given by doctors because they don’t want to admit that it’s already dementia ( also known as moderate cognitive decline), and 2) our loved ones often ‘showtime’ at doctors’ offices . Showtime means they can be perceived as more competent than they are for a short amount of time or by people who don’t know them well.

  • Lethe
    Lethe Member Posts: 147
    100 Comments 100 Likes 100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I agree with all the others. Trust your gut. My husband had a driving test with an occupational therapist when he had MCI. He never got to the actual behind the wheel part. His reflexes were too slow and his visual perception was off so he failed the first part and that was it. They notify the registry and he had his license revoked. He of course thought he was just fine and it was my fault and the occupational therapists for loosing his license. But I sure breathed a sigh of relief. It’s hard for them and for you.

  • harshedbuzz
    harshedbuzz Member Posts: 7,066
    Ninth Anniversary 2,500 Insightfuls Reactions 1,500 Likes 5000 Comments
    Member

    Piling on here.

    Many doctors give MCI as a placeholding diagnosis at the time of the initial assessment with the intention of revising it in 6-12 months at the follow-up based on progression in that time. A lot of doctors avoid the driving discussion at the first appointment— or entirely. Some feel it's a family, rather than medical, discussion and others don't want to be the bearer of such news and damaging their relationship with the PWD. Many PWD refuse a second appointment because they're angry about being told they have dementia and/or can't drive.

    If the MCI was based on the score from quick testing in office using a scale like MMSE, MoCA or SLUMS it might not be accurate at all. Some people bring a lot of cognitive reserve to these tests and do better on them than one would expect based on how they function day-to-day. My dad tested in the MCI range on MoCa 6 months before he died. He was stage 6 and had spent the drive to the office insisting that he didn't recognize the town we were in (he'd had business there when he retired) had moved all the streets around replaced all of the buildings with new ones (historically registered Victorians, FTR).

    After he "aced" the test, he bragged the entire way back to the lobby about being "off the charts". When I turned my back to give the ticket to the valet, he wandered off and got into the car with a random woman. I'll never forget the look on her face.

    HB

  • Lisa1022
    Lisa1022 Member Posts: 19
    25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Likes
    Member

    Our relationship is going to look more like parent, child isn't it? He told me not to treat him like he's not competent, it's making him angry. It's so wearying to think that this is going to be how it is. Our son was diagnosed with autism 35 years ago and this feels so similar. I'm so sad.

  • Lisa1022
    Lisa1022 Member Posts: 19
    25 Care Reactions 10 Comments 5 Likes
    Member

    Thank you, this is all so helpful and I don't feel so crazy anymore.

  • harshedbuzz
    harshedbuzz Member Posts: 7,066
    Ninth Anniversary 2,500 Insightfuls Reactions 1,500 Likes 5000 Comments
    Member

    @Lisa1022

    It's hard to say how you'll feel going forward or how your relationship will change or not. No judgement, it's a is what it is thing.

    Oddly, my dad morphed into thinking of my mom as being "like his mother who takes good care of him" long before mom felt the tenderness that a mother would have.

    I have a son on spectrum, too. I was always struck by the overlap in symptoms— sensory processing glitches, lack of empathy, inertia, sleep issues, limited diet, poor executive function and language glitches. DS was in college when dad moved back to the area and it felt, at times, like he was less autistic than dad.
    HB

  • Quilting brings calm
    Quilting brings calm Member Posts: 3,317
    Sixth Anniversary 1,000 Insightfuls Reactions 1,000 Likes 2500 Comments
    Member

    -I was always struck by the overlap in symptoms— sensory processing glitches, lack of empathy, inertia, sleep issues, limited diet, poor executive function and language glitche—

    My thought on that is it all has to do with the brain. The brain is not working in the way we expect. For a person with dementia, it’s deteriorating. For a person with autism, it’s just wired differently.

Commonly Used Abbreviations


DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more