Getting Doctors to Listen

I am so sick of being told Hubs memory and executive function issues being called "normal aging". I've been with this guy almost 30 years and this is not that. He was diagnosed with MCI and now they are trying to back step it because he passes the MoCa. We requested a 2nd opinion with neurology. That request seems to be lost. (We are Kaiser NoCa) Neurology sent the request back to GP and referred him to a class for ways to manage memory loss. Which he already took. Here is an example. (I need to add both of our careers were in the tech fiield.) He told me the BP cuff is broken. It wont charge. He looked at it at least 3 times. So he got another one. I just looked at it. It is not rechargeable i changed the batteries and it works fine. I dont see that as normal. He memory is really bad. I have learned not to say remember when we …. Because he wont. We are watching the news and a story we have discussed previously comes up and he has no memory of it.

He is very anxious and has been diagnosed with depression. We heard from multiple people that the wellbutrin he's taking for the depression can cause anxiety so under his doctor's care he cut the dose in half and the anxiety has improved but his memory is still really bad. Yet he passes the MoCa. I call BS. hes had brain scans and those are normal.

I am so frustrated. The one blessing I have is he knows he has a problem and wants to get help.

Comments

  • ronda b
    ronda b Member Posts: 472
    250 Care Reactions 100 Insightfuls Reactions 100 Likes 100 Comments
    Member

    Has he been tested by a neuropshycologist?

  • Iris L.
    Iris L. Member Posts: 5,787
    Legacy Membership 5000 Comments 1,000 Likes 500 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member
    edited November 12

    Depression can indeed present with memory loss and executive dysfunction. Intensive neurocognitive testing performed by a neuropsychologist can help in clarifying the diagnosis. It is also important to treat major Depression aggressively with medication and psychotherapy for at least eight weeks. If there is no improvement, it is more likely that the diagnosis will be a dementia. A geriatric psychiatrist may be consulted. In addition, review all medications for memory loss side effects.

    Iris

  • AlekoW
    AlekoW Member Posts: 90
    100 Care Reactions 25 Likes 10 Comments 5 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    Yeah, I hear ya—that sort of broadbrushing, dismissive, 'meh, everyone ages' crap is crazymakin'.

    Agree with ronda b & Iris L., neuropsych testing (the 4-5 hour one) will be more definitive then MoCA alone. Has he had the gene (blood) test, an MRI-Brain & a PETAmyloid scans? The constellation of testing can aid in more definitive (un-ignorable) Dx.

    FWIW, we recently had a Neuro PA tell us all the test results didn't matter this was all in our heads. (So mad I could spit). Contrast this to UCLA's Easton Center for Alzheimer's & Dementia who concurred with our first neuro and noted declines from the MoCA test that was 29, 28, 22 across three of them. The one administered by the PA who denied everything? 30—because the PA didn't look/listen at/to my DW who failed 3 elements in the MoCA. My DW's PCP & her UCLA neuro shook her head in disbelief. So, all that to say, this shirt happens far more often than should be acceptable, IMHO.

  • H1235
    H1235 Member Posts: 2,466
    1,000 Likes 1,000 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Care Reactions 1000 Comments
    Member

    When I first took mom to the pcp the doctor did a quick in office assessment (not sure which one). She did fine. Showed no problems at all. I insisted on a referral to a neurologist. They did an extensive two hour evaluation. Not only was she diagnosed with dementia, we were told she was no longer safe to drive or live alone. This appointment was only a few months after the pcp visit with no real decline between visits. Has he had blood tests. I think low B12 can cause memory issues and Lyme disease is another possibility to have ruled out. Keep pushing! Your husband is lucky to have you as his advocate.

  • Michele P
    Michele P Member Posts: 572
    500 Insightfuls Reactions 500 Comments 250 Likes 25 Care Reactions
    Member
    edited November 13

    I agree with others that he should be tested by a neuropsychologist. Your husband might have a high cognitive reserve that allowed him to pass the tests he has been given so far.

  • BPS
    BPS Member Posts: 569
    500 Likes 500 Care Reactions 500 Comments 250 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    My wifes PCP didn't really take it very serious at first. She had been to a neurologist and had a diagnoses, but she seemed pretty good in a controlled setting like a doctors office when I was there. I gave her a test that I got off line and then took it in with us to her visit and showed it to him. I didn't know if he would look at it because it came off line but he did and then he realized she was farther along than it appeared. SAGE (Self-Administered Gerocognitive Exam)

  • notequipped
    notequipped Member Posts: 186
    100 Likes 100 Comments 25 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    Honestly with what you’ve described, I would try to locate someone to do a neuro psych evaluation independently of the medical system especially since your husband is cooperative and wants help. I’ve recently discovered that the cash price of many medical tests are much less expensive than the ‘negotiated insurance price’. (MRIs, urgent care visits, etc all have a less expensive cash price in my area.) I really like the neuro psych guy that my Mom went to. He operates pretty independently. I would imagine that with a chat similar to what you’ve shared above you would be able to find someone. You shouldn’t have to but it might be worth a shot.

    Another vote for having SAGE tests handy, too. There are 4 versions of it to try to prevent learning the test. It got the ball rolling for my Mom.

  • Timmyd
    Timmyd Member Posts: 433
    500 Likes 250 Insightfuls Reactions 250 Care Reactions 100 Comments
    Member

    I have heard it is common for some doctors to treat memory issues in older adults with an attitude of "therapeutic nihilism". Essentially a lack of interest in the condition emanating from the belief that there are not effective treatments.

  • JoseyWales
    JoseyWales Member Posts: 654
    Tenth Anniversary 500 Comments 100 Care Reactions 25 Insightfuls Reactions
    Member

    I used to be really, really angry about the lack of diagnosis for my husband. Beginning around age 44, he visited many doctors, neurologists, psychologists and had THREEE different exams with a neuropsychologist over several years. Everyone said depression & anxiety. Nope. It's some kind of "neurological degenerative disorder." That's exactly what his paperwork says even now. He's now 62, and has been in stage 7 for several years. Likely several more years to go, because his body is super healthy.

    Here's the truth - there's nothing that can be done for most types of dementia. It's going to progress no matter what. Yes, a diagnosis is nice. But I look back and think that it would have changed nothing. We'd still be here in this same situation. Once you rule out all the causes that can be treated, nothing else matters.

Commonly Used Abbreviations


DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more