Struggling to involve siblings
New here, I am struggling to get my brothers involved in our mom’s care. My husband and I are very close to her emotionally and proximity. I have a brother that is 20 min away and another that is hours away. We did thankfully get her moved into an independent living facility that provides her meals and socialization. I attend all her medical appointments, my husband does finances and I check in daily, but that gets exhausting. I texted them asking for more support because I am going through some struggles in my personal life and need them to check in with her more than every few weeks. They said let us know what you need. The one got defensive and said they ask her if they can do anything and mom’s reply is “Sis” is taking care of it. Just frustrating and don’t know how to reply.
Comments
-
If you haven't seen the SNL skit "sister" from this week, treat yourself.
- Give specific tasks to them. When someone isn't fully involved, it's hard to know what to offer.
- Talk, don't text. It's so easy to misread and make things worse. (Ask me how I know.)
- Tell mom, and give brothers permission to tell mom, "I have a big project at work (or appropriate fiblet) and Bro 1 is going to be doing X for you the rest of this year." I love you and we will make sure we're taking care of you. Repeat as necessary, don't apologize or over explain.
- If needed, tell brothers what you won't be doing anymore, and what the consequence to mom will be if one if them doesn't do it. Don't apologize or over explain.
- Take advice from an only child as seriously, or not, as you want. But, I've lived some. :-)
3 -
Yes, you can try giving them specific tasks - but they have to actually do them and not accept mom saying you will do it. The truth is that getting siblings - especially long distance ones - to do helpful things is a crapshoot. Sometimes they will, sometimes they won’t, sometimes them being involved does more harm than good, sometimes they just clash with you because tbey can.
Ask them to take over calling her on a regular basis ( one calls Monday, Wednesday, Friday, the other does Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday). You call on Sundays and whenever else during the week you find time. They can send you a text telling you if mom says she needed anything or didn’t sound ok.
Are you sure you have mom in the correct level of care? By the time my mom had her diagnosis, she needed assisted living, not independent. My parent’s short stay in independent living long distance from us is what brought her issues to our attention. The cleaning woman called because mom couldn’t figure out her medication.
2 -
I agree QBC on all points. I have a difficult brother that wants to be kept informed and pretends to be actively involved, but does nothing to help. Be careful what you wish for. My brother often works against me to make things considerably more difficult. That’s worse than not helping! You can try to get them to help, but at some point you might find it’s taking more effort to beg, plead and cry for help than it is to just do it yourself or find professional help. Along those lines independent living for a person with dementia is not going to work for very long (if ever), especially if you’re not getting the help you need. If they don’t step up I would consider recognizing defeat and consider the your next steps (more professional care, probably assisted living). I ran myself into the ground and stressed myself to the point of panic attacks before I finally lowered my expectations to zero and started limiting contact (with my brother) to avoid the added stress. I also started a low dose anxiety medication. I hated the idea of medication, but I’m glad I finally gave in. So sorry you are going through this. If you haven’t seen snl sister skit you should look it up. So accurate!
2 -
Very true, mom may need to be retrained too. Just don't cave in to selective incompetence "but I don't know HOW to put paper in the copier". Flip side, if you wanted bro to put the green plaid flannel sheets on and he washed and used the same ones, you have to be OK with that. A speaker named Brenda Dieztmann has a helpful way to organize your to-do list. A. What has to get done perfectly, B. What has to get done well, C. What just has to get done. I think most of us caregivers have some things in the A list that don't need to be.
Ditto on rethinking level of care.
3 -
we have had discussions about the level of care she is in currently. Luckily the facility has assisted living and memory care all in the same complex. Most recently she went on med packing because of a medicine mix up. She can manage daily self care and keep her place picked up, walks her dog. I just don’t want to feel obligated every day as I am struggling with emotions of recent sentencing of my son to prison. So I told my local brother he needs to include mom in their holidays because I don’t have the energy and mental capacity to do Thanksgiving. And my husband is going to be away with his aging mom. Thank you all!
1 -
I see 3 pieces to this scenario:
The first is that you and your DH have very competently cared for mom to this point and that might leave them feeling a little intimidated about inserting themselves into what is your plan of care. Cobbling onto what QBC said, maybe they need some direction. My SIL and BIL were in-home caregivers for my MIL for 5 years. We wanted to help and SIL tendered a suggestion that I, as a stay-at-home parent, could bring DS (the apple of his grandma's eye) and come stay with MIL while her family went on vacation. It's only now as a caregiver that I get what a break not being in charge for 2 weeks was.
Do you need a break from the emotional weight of "checking-in"? Maybe take 2 days off a week that you assign to each brother. Let them call or visit and give you a break.
The second piece is mom. She's feeding this inequity. It could be she sees you as the logical caregiver— maybe the oldest/youngest/closest or daughter. She might not be re-trainable, but maybe you could assign them a job to brighten her day. One easy enough thing would for one to come at a mealtime and bring her a treat or attend an activity with her so that becomes his "thing with her".
The third piece is you. This is no judgement, I do the same, but given that mom is in a facility, is the daily well check necessary? If you feel it is, it could be that IL is not the appropriate placement at this point in her dementia. You might need less support from your brothers if you and mom were getting it from the team in her facility.
I know for me, anxiety plays into this behavior for me. I am hardwired this way— a planner/person-in-charge to my very core. The responsibility for the emotional and physical wellbeing of my parents weighs heavily. One thing that has helped is medication. For me, a low dose SSRI helps. You'd be surprised how many here also take something when the caregiving starts to impact them. YMMV.
HB2 -
I am the DIL, and we just brought my MIL to her daughter's house to stay until January. I am ready to spit nails at her daughter for her absolutely crappy attitude. Originally the plan was that the two siblings would split the care although my husband would always manage the finances. Once she moved here, my SIL texted that "it was just easier if Mama stayed with y'all all the time."
So instead of six months of the year off from 24-7 caregiving, we get six weeks now, and only because I forced the issue. When we brought her up there, my SIL was simmering with resentment. Angry that we said she shouldn't have crackers, cake and ice cream on demand (prediabetic, stage 4 kidney failure). Angry that we didn't bring her enough Depends and Poise pads for six weeks, or Boost or the protein snacks we've been using. Just pissed off in general that we didn't make her life as easy as possible.
The hilarious part is that my MIL has been crying for months that she missed her daughter, that she was so good to her and took such good care of her while we were buying our house so she could move in. About an hour after arriving, she turned to me and said, "These kids are getting on my nerves. Ask my son if I can go back with y'all."
1 -
My thoughts:
Give them very specific/prescriptive instructions on what is needed
If that doesn't work, bring in an outside facilitator to outline how care needs to happen in next year, and have that person be the bad guy communicating responsibilities that could or should be split; often siblings just don't listen to other siblings
If that doesnt work, forge ahead—if you have asked, and they don't deliver, assemble your own care team
Obviously powers of attorney, managing finances is a key piece of this. If you don't hold either poa or both, it's going to be difficult. If you are at this point, I would discuss the situation with a geriatric care manager, who hopefully understands a bit of legal, and figure out a plan. I would suggest an attorney first; however, they are very costly so thinking it may make sense to be money conscious first. Sadly it is only going to get more complicated. Your mom is so fortunate to have you looking out for her.
1
Commonly Used Abbreviations
DH = Dear Husband
DW= Dear Wife, Darling Wife
LO = Loved One
ES = Early Stage
EO = Early Onset
FTD = Frontotemporal Dementia
VD = Vascular Dementia
MC = Memory Care
AL = Assisted Living
POA = Power of Attorney
Read more
Categories
- All Categories
- 715 Living With Alzheimer's or Dementia
- 416 I Am Living With Alzheimer's or Other Dementia
- 299 I Am Living With Younger Onset Alzheimer's
- 19.3K Supporting Someone Living with Dementia
- 5.9K I Am a Caregiver (General Topics)
- 9.5K Caring For a Spouse or Partner
- 3.5K Caring for a Parent
- 254 Caring Long Distance
- 208 Supporting Those Who Have Lost Someone
- 13 Discusiones en Español
- 1 Vivir con Alzheimer u Otra Demencia
- 1 Vivo con Alzheimer u Otra Demencia
- Vivo con Alzheimer de Inicio Más Joven
- 12 Prestación de Cuidado
- 3 Soy Cuidador (Temas Generales)
- 8 Cuidar de un Padre
- 23 ALZConnected Resources
- View Discussions For People Living with Dementia
- View Discussions for Caregivers
- Discusiones en Español
- Browse All Discussions
- Dementia Resources
- 8 Account Assistance
- 15 Help
